The complete automotive resource for buyers, sellers, and owners like you.
------ Advertisement. Support us by joining the Roadfly Inner Circle to optionally hide this banner ad. ------
Tirerack.com Wheel and Tire Home | Post Reply | Preferences | Search | Archives | Old Archives | FAQ | Notify the Admins

Location: Home > Forums > Wheel & Tire Forum

Roadfly Forums
Wheels and Tires Message Board  Sponsored by: The Tire Rack

---------- Advertisement ----------
Click here
Welcome to Roadfly
Roadfly Official Time:
Sep 6, 2008 2:45am EDT
Search this Forum:

More search options
---------- Advertisement ----------

Click here
Community Links
Events Calendar
Member Photo Galleries
Member Car Blogs
IC© Membership
IC© Photo Hosting
Roadfly Stickers
Newest Forums Newest Forums at Roadfly
BMW X6 (E71)
Jaguar XF (2008)
For Sale Forum
Group Buy Forum
Ferrari Forums
Lamborghini Forums
Maserati Forums
Roadfly Lounges
Regional Forums
Automotive Related Forums
General Discussion Forums
BMW X5 (E70)
Ultra Garage
Car Insurance
BMW M3 (E92 M3)
BMW Z4 Coupe (E86)
Auto Shows
Jaguar XK
Inner Circle
Porsche Cayman
Corvette C6/Z06 Forum
Specialty Automotive Forums for all Cars, Trucks and SUVs
Audio/Video Forum
Car Insurance Forum
Detailing Forum
Financing/Leasing Forum
Forced Induction Forum
Specialty Lighting Forum
Models (miniatures)
Lemon Law Forum
Ultra Garage Forum
Wheel and Tire Forum
Test Forum
Car, Truck and SUV Forums at Roadfly
+ Bentley Forums
+ BMW Forums
+ Cadillac Forums
+ Chevrolet Forums
+ Ferrari Forums
+ Jaguar Forums
+ Lamborghini Forums
+ Lotus Forums
+ Mercedes-Benz Forums
+ Maserati Forums
+ MINI Forums
+ Porsche Forums
+ General Discussion
+ Marketplace Forums
Roadfly General Forums
Alerts Forum
Help Desk
Inner Circle
General Lounge Forums
Politics Lounge Forum


  
Mod-O-Matic (beta!): Please vote with care. You must be logged in to use Mod-O-Matic Move post to: For Sale | Group Buy | Off Topic | NWS/Adult    Remove due to Spam/Troll | Prohibited       Highlight as: Informative | Success Story
 
Author:  
Dave on 2008-04-18 at 21:57:11(posted from: Host: 71-219-227-163.clsp.qwest.net IP: 71.219.227.163) 
    
Subject:  
Manufacturer siping vs. aftermarket siping (167 views) (256 thread views) 
Message: The Discount Tire web site has a page extolling the virtues of siping. There's also a mini-FAQ containing this question: "Why Don't My Tires Come Siped From the Manufacturer?"

An excellent question that I have wondered myself. If siping really does confer all the claimed performance benefits, any manufacturer that allows unsiped tires go out the door would be at a considerable competitive disadvantage.

Their answer: "To sipe (in mass production) after the molding process would be too expensive and time consuming for the manufacturer."

I have to call B.S. on this answer. Any process done in a mass-produced manner is going to be less expensive than doing the same process on a one-off, now-and-then basis. If a manufacturer has some employees doing siping full time, they're going to get really good at it and do it more efficiently than the guy at Discount Tire. The manufacturer could probably even find a way to automate the process and bring the labor cost close to zero.

As I understand it, these days tread patterns are designed with sophisticated computer models. Those models could take into account manufacturer siping... but aftermarket siping would do God-knows-what to the performance of that exquisitely designed tread.

In short, for those who believe in siping, they'd be better off having the manufacturer do it than the local shop.

Does anybody agree/disagree?

 
Link: http://www.discounttire.com/dtcs/tireSiping.dos 
 



 Wheels and Tires Message Board | Message Posts:




 Post Reply:


Posting form not available.

The most likely reason you are seeing this message is that you have not yet
signed in to your Roadfly account.
Make sure you are logged in to your Roadfly account to ensure you don't see this message in the future.



Questions, comments, or problems, please visit the Roadfly help desk.
Roadfly.com Logo © 1997 - 2008 Jump Internet Inc. All rights reserved.