The complete automotive resource for buyers, sellers, and owners like you.
Detailing Message Board | Post Reply | Preferences | Search | Archives | Boards FAQ | Notify the Admins

Location: Home > Forums > Detailing Forum

Roadfly Forums
Detailing and Car Care Forum

---------- Advertisement ----------
Click here CR Spotless
Would you rather spend time driving your car or drying it? With a deionizing water system from CR Spotless, you can now wash, rinse and walk away! It really is that easy. Visit our website and check out all the uses for *spot-free* water- Concours, Daily Driver, RV, Household Windows, you name it- anywhere water spots drive you nuts!
866-530-9993

chuck@crspotless.com
www.crspotless.com

Welcome to Roadfly
Roadfly Official Time:
Jul 4, 2009 6:40pm EDT
Search this Forum:

More search options
---------- Advertisement ----------
Your Ad Here!
The most effective ads anywhere! No rotation, ads are always visible.
Roadfly AdMarket
Community Links
Events Calendar
Member Photo Galleries
Member Car Blogs
IC© Membership
IC© Photo Hosting
Roadfly Stickers
Newest Forums Newest Forums at Roadfly
Porsche Panamera
BMW X6 (E71)
Jaguar XF (2008)
For Sale Forum
Group Buy Forum
Ferrari Forums
Lamborghini Forums
Maserati Forums
Roadfly Lounges
Regional Forums
Automotive Related Forums
General Discussion Forums
BMW X5 (E70)
Ultra Garage
Car Insurance
BMW M3 (E92 M3)
BMW Z4 Coupe (E86)
Auto Shows
Jaguar XK
Inner Circle
Porsche Cayman
Corvette C6/Z06 Forum
Specialty Automotive Forums for all Cars, Trucks and SUVs
Audio/Video Forum
Car Insurance Forum
Detailing Forum
Financing/Leasing Forum
Forced Induction Forum
Specialty Lighting Forum
Models (miniatures)
Lemon Law Forum
Ultra Garage Forum
Wheel and Tire Forum
Test Forum
Car, Truck and SUV Forums at Roadfly
+ Bentley Forums
+ BMW Forums
+ Cadillac Forums
+ Chevrolet Forums
+ Ferrari Forums
+ Jaguar Forums
+ Lamborghini Forums
+ Lotus Forums
+ Mercedes-Benz Forums
+ Maserati Forums
+ MINI Forums
+ Porsche Forums
+ General Discussion
+ Marketplace Forums
Roadfly General Forums
Alerts Forum
Help Desk
Inner Circle
General Lounge Forums
Politics Lounge Forum


  
Mod-O-Matic (beta!): Please vote with care. You must be logged in to use Mod-O-Matic Move post to: For Sale | Group Buy | Off Topic | NWS/Adult    Remove due to Spam/Troll | Prohibited       Highlight as: Informative | Success Story
 
Author:  
Steve L on 2004-08-07 at 13:42:25(posted from: Host: cdm-66-233-249-126.bnvl.cox-internet.com IP: 66.233.249.126) 
    
Subject:  
FINAL RESULTS: 7-PRODUCT TEST DONE (28104 views) (39362 thread views) 
Message:
7 Product Mini Test:
Some of the latest products tested and reviewed


Note: This was NOT an official Guru Reports Test. Your results may (and probably will) vary. All testing was performed on my own time and does not reflect Guru Reports or its testing methodologies - this test was 100% independent and conducted under blind conditions with 3 people providing their own, personal opinions of the waxes for their appearance, performance, ease of use and durability. Do not allow any portion of this test to influence your potential buying decision - it's simply a comparison based on observations, opinion and personal experience in my unique environment.


THE PRODUCTS

- Eagle One Nano Wax
- Einszett Glanz Wax
- Meguiar's NXT Next Generation Wax
- Tropi-Care TC-3 Premium Car Polish
- Turtle Wax Platinum Series UltraGloss
- Wolfgang
- Zaino Z2


THE PANEL

My trusty, red, late 90's GM deck lid. The panel was washed with Dawn, clayed twice (using Wayne's Towels new clay bar), washed, wiped down with PPG PrepSol, and washed with Dawn. A final wipedown with a 50/50 concentration of 91% Isopropyl Alcohol and water ensured there was no residue left on the panel. Old marker lines remained from a previous test, even after all of the prep work... gotta' love those Magnum 44 bold black markers! No other preparations were performed to the panel - no polishing, no glazing; just clean-clean-clean.


THE CRITERIA and CONDITIONS

All products were applied exactly per manufacturer instructions. Whenever possible, the supplied applicators and prep products were used as recommended by the manufacturer. All residues were wiped off with a microfiber cloth (a new cloth was used for each product to protect against cross-contamination).

The products were applied to the panel in segregated areas, meaning that each product had "bare space" around it. The bare space served as control areas to determine when a product had finished offering protection. It also served as a buffer space between products to further help prevent against cross contamination.

Products were initially applied on 5/31/04, weather conditions were perfect: 74F, 50% humidity, and partly cloudy. The products were allowed to "rest" for 1 hour after application and initial evaluation. The long-term panel was left outside, exposed to the elements for the duration of the test. Using a Raytek infra-red temperature gun, panel temperatures were taken periodically, along with ambient temperature readings and weather conditions.

Once a week, the long-term panel was washed with P21S Bodywork Shampoo and blotted dry with a microfiber towel. After washing, the panel was allowed to rest for 15 minutes before evaluation. No quick detailers were used during the test. Volunteers subjectively graded the appearance of the products, and objective measurements were taken to determine optical and durability qualities. Initial beading ratings were taken to compare for later in the test. Bead measurements were performed using my proprietary system of determining the average size (depth and radius) of water beads on a panel after a 1-minute cold water spray.

All grades are assigned on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the highest possible grade.


WEATHER & PANEL TEMPERATURES - WEEK BY WEEK

During the initial week, the weather was unusually warm, with temperatures in the high 80's during the day, and evening temperatures averaging in the high 60's. It was sunny and humid, with one very heavy rainstorm (including small hail) 36 hours after the products were initially evaluated. Panel temperature during the week averaged approximately 114-degrees during the day.

Week 2's weather included more rain, and more heat. Temperatures regularly hit 90-degrees during the day, which caused a slight increase in average panel temperature to 118-degrees. Rain was sporadic but heavy. It rained 4 out of the 7 days of the test.

Week 3 was a nice week, as far as the weather goes. It was sunny nearly everyday, with highs in the low 90's and lows in the mid 60's. It was rather humid all week, with a fair amount of dew being present in the morning (dew point was around 72F all week).

Week 4 saw some severe storms - one of which knocked out our power for 2 days and took down a tree. Temps were hot - low-to-mid 90's during the day, with a mixture of sporadic rain and high sunshine. As a result, many of the panel's sections became waterspotted/etched. Apologies for the picture "hue" - white balance was off, and I didn't want to use Photoshop to correct anything - pictures are *exactly* as they came from camera, save for resizing.

Week 5 was hot. Really hot. The low temperature at night was usually in the low to mid-70's. Sun was relentless - it bore down on the test panel with out mercy. No rain this week.

Week 6 was hotter than week 5. Highs nudged 100-degrees with a UV index of at least 9 every day. Had a few sporadic, heavy thunderstorms. Panel temperature averaged well over 130 degrees during the afternoon hours.

Week 7 was a repeat of week 6. Very hot, panel temperatures in the high 130's. When we washed the panel at the end of week 7, we did so at 10:00am, and the temperature was already 88F.





Eagle One Nano WaxPRODUCT #1:
Eagle One Nano Wax $9.95, 16oz


Initial Notes: I liked the packaging of this product - it comes in a nifty little box that includes a microfiber towel and applicator. I didn't care for the "pump" nature of the product, and was surprised by its somewhat watery consistency. Eagle One did not recommend any specific prep process, so product was applied as directed - product did exhibit some cleaning ability as it removed most of the marker lines while applying. Had a nice, waxy aroma with just a hint of fragrance. Applied nicely and evenly, removed with some resistance and left a nice initial finish. Surface felt slick and smooth.
Application: 10
Removal: 7
Packaging: 7
Instructions: 9
2-week Notes: Unbelievably, the product seems to have all but expired after just two weeks. The test volunteers were left scratching their heads as we watched the water simply pool and collect on the panel. When we dried it, it was squeaky clean, and the optics had dropped significantly from original readings.



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
8
8
8
7
7
8
10
8
8.08
Week 2
6
6
6
6
6
2
1
4
4.63
Final (Week 4)
5
5
4
4
4
1
0
2
3.13
Average
6.33
6.33
6
5.67
5.67
3.67
3.67
4.67
5.28
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)

Eagle One Nano Wax Eagle One Nano Wax
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)

Eagle One Nano Wax Eagle One Nano Wax
Overall Score:
5.28
Final Notes: I think it's safe to say that after 4 weeks the Nano is "no more." Despite spraying it with a fine mist of water to try and coax some beading from it, the panel simply held on to the water. Optics were down a fair amount, slickness was completely gone and there were waterspots that wouldn't remove with a wash. Officially "dead" and won't be tested any more in this test.




Einszett Glanz Wax (1Z)PRODUCT #2:
Einszett Glanz Wax $13.95, 16.9oz


Initial Notes: I've used this product in the past but never "officially" tested it side-by-side against other products. The consistency of the product is very watery - almost like water itself. Noticed a strong cleaning effect while applying - and the aroma was very solventy, so my guess is that the solvents are acting as chemical cleaners. Product goes on "clear" and dries to a white-ish haze. Noticed some streaking after residue was removed. Initial shine wasn't as good as other products, and surface felt only moderately slick. Removal was only moderately difficult - slightly harder than Nano Wax.
Application: 8
Removal: 6
Packaging: 7
Instructions: 9
2-Week Notes: Water is beading nicely, and the product seems to be doing its job. Optics remained steady, and the heat and rain hasn't had any apparent effect on the panel. Beads are consistent, small and deep - just what we're looking for. Has lost some slickness, but wasn't real slick to start with.



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
6
6
6
7
7
6
10
7
7.08
Week 2
6
6
6
7
7
5
9
7
6.63
Week 4
6
6
6
5
5
4
5
7
5.5
Average
6.40
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Einszett Glanz Wax Beading Einszett Glanz Wax Beading
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Einszett Glanz Wax Beading Einszett Glanz Wax Beading
Week 7:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Einszett Glanz Wax Beading Einszett Glanz Wax Beading
4-Week Notes: Looks like it's going to be a slug-out between Glanz and Zaino. While the Glanz took a bit of a hit over weeks 3 and 4, it's still doing worlds better than any of the other "over-the-counter" products. Optics about the same - perhaps a slight decrease, but it appears to be protecting well. No waterspots noted when washing.
Overall Score:
6.40
7-Week Notes: After a very hot 5th and 6th week, it appears as though Einzsett has thrown in the towel. The beading is completely dead. We noticed it was starting to suffer after the 5th week, but didn't expect it to fall off as severely as it did during the 6th week. If you look around the panel, you can see how all of the marker lines have faded away - the sun really beat on this panel. Even at 6-weeks of "life," the results were 3x better than all of the other products (save for Z2). Handily beat 6 products and is well deserving of a strong second-place finish.




Tropi-Care TC-3 Premium Car PolishPRODUCT #3:
Meguiar's NXT $14.95, 18oz


Initial Notes: Nice creamy consistency, and I like the aroma of it, although some folks have complained that it's too strong. A tad pricey when compared to the alternatives. Applied nicely, about the same as the Nano Wax, despite being a little thicker. Dried quickly, removed fairly easily. Had some light streaking after application. Also noted cleaning capability in the product, stronger than Nano Wax but not as strong as Glanz. Surface was darker than bare control panel, and left a fairly slick, smooth surface behind. Optics were pretty good, but a bit muted. Neighbors noted it looked deeper than bare control.
Application: 10
Removal: 8
Packaging: 9
Instructions: 9
2-week Notes: We had durability problems with NXT during our winter tests, and had higher hopes based on what we've read elsewhere about this product's durability, but once again, durability seems to be the weak point. After just 2 short weeks, our test panel was squeaky clean and water was clinging and pooling. :-(



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
8
8
9
6
7
8
10
8
8.13
Week 2
6
6
7
5
5
1
1
5
4.5
Week 4
5
5
4
4
4
0
0
2
3
Average
6.33
6.33
6.67
5
5.33
3
3.67
5
5.21
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Meguiar's NXT Water Beading Meguiar's NXT Water Beading
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Meguiar's NXT Water Beading Meguiar's NXT Water Beading
Overall Score:
5.21
Final Notes: While it was mostly cooked after 2 weeks, it's clearly done after the 4 week period. Not sure how some people are getting such "long term" durability from the product - this is the second time I've gotten less than 4 weeks from it. No doubt the Booster Wax adds to the durability - that must be the key (same could be said for many other products). Sure does look nice at beginning - only wish look would stick around. Had waterspots after panel was washed.




Tropi-Care TC-3 Premium Car PolishPRODUCT #4:
Tropi-Care TC-3 $12.95, 8oz


Initial Notes: Relatively new product that I'd played with in the past but again, never really tested seriously. Decided to use the TC-8 Swirl Cutter ($15.95, 8oz) as a prep product just to prevent any problems or complaints with the test procedures. TC-8 worked well, was easy to apply and remove, helped clean the surface. Noticed that TC-3 has cleaning properties as well. Both products have a nice fruity smell, but solvents can be smelled underneath the fruity scent. TC-3 applied easily, removed with slightly more difficulty than NXT. Surface felt smooth and fairly slick, optics were ok but not what I'd expect from a true polymer. All in all, OK initally, but pricey.
Application: 10
Removal: 7
Packaging: 5
Instructions: 9
2-week Notes: Despite having heavy initial beading, the product appears to have died off rather quickly - panel isn't beading water; it just sits and pools on the panel - just like the non-waxed control portion. Testers couldn't detect any slickness, and optics were dropping off slightly.



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
7
7
7
6
6
7
9
7
7.25
Week 2
5
5
5
6
6
1
1
5
4.25
Week 4
3
3
3
3
3
0
0
2
2.13
Average
5
5
5
5
5
2.67
3.33
4.67
4.54
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Tropi-Care Water Beading Tropi-Care Water Beading (Week 2)
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Tropi-Care Water Beading Tropi-Care Water Beading (Week 2)
Overall Score:
4.54
Final Notes: Sigh. Based on initial talk about this product, I'd hoped it would fare well, but it hasn't. Pictures speak for themselves - not much else I can add. Had waterspots after panel was washed.




Turtle Wax Platinum Ultra Gloss WaxPRODUCT #5:
Turtle Wax Platinum Series Ultra Gloss $7.95, 16oz


Initial Notes: If you're like me, you're sick of being beaten over the head with ads for this product. Product was very easy to apply and remove - perhaps the easiest of the bunch, but I do wish bottle had a pour spout. Did notice some moderate cleaning ability (about like Nano Wax). Decent aroma, but I noticed tiny "beads" of something (my guess is silicone?) in the product... perhaps it was exposed to moisture? Felt very slick when residue was removed, and left the panel looking deep, albiet a bit muted - almost like NXT.
Application: 10
Removal: 10
Packaging: 7
Instructions: 9
2-week Notes: From a personal standpoint, I had high hopes for this product, but after 2-weeks, it appears to have all but checked out. The panel wasn't beading water and it felt dry and clingy to the touch - definitely not slick like when we started. The testers were amazed with how quickly so many products "fell off."



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
8
8
9
8
8
9
9
8
8.58
Week 2
6
6
6
7
7
2
1
5
5.00
Week 4
4
4
4
3
3
0
0
3
2.63
Average
6
6
6.33
6
6
3.67
3.33
5.33
5.40
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Turtle Wax Platinum Water Beading (Week 2) Turtle Wax Platinum Water Beading (Week 2)
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Turtle Wax Platinum Water Beading (Week 2) Turtle Wax Platinum Water Beading (Week 2)
Overall Score:
5.40
Final Notes: Again, from a personal standpoint, I'm disappointed. I really thought this product would perform better than it did for us. It was a dream to apply and remove, and it looked pretty nice during the first week. Noticed waterspots after panel was washed.




WolfGang Deep Gloss Paint SealantPRODUCT #6:
WolfGang Deep Gloss Concours Kit $49.95, 16oz bottles

Initial Notes: Definitely not for the thrifty - with shipping, this kit cost nearly $60, but thankfully it includes a few microfiber towels and applicators. Nicely packaged, and a decent aroma, but the hint of solvent was detected underneath the scenting. Noticed pretty good cleaning ability from the Pre-Wax Polish Enhancer, (which applied and removed easily) and it left surface clean, slick and glossy. Deep Gloss Paint Sealant applied and removed easily, left a slight amount of hazing, and surface looked and felt the same as before. Surface looked a little better than NXT, felt slightly less slick than the Turtle Wax Platinum.
Application: 9
Removal: 9
Packaging: 10
Instructions: 10
2-week Notes: Despite its high cost and the initial reviews, the product doesn't seem to be holding up as well as we would have expected. Lost almost all of its slickness and isn't exactly sheeting water - testers noted that it "would make a great reflecting pool," meaning that water clung. We'll see how it is next week.



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
8
8
8
7
7
8
10
8
8.33
Week 2
6
6
6
5
5
1
1
6
4.50
Week 4
4
4
4
4
4
0
0
4
3
Average
6
6
6
5.33
5.33
3
3.67
6
5.28
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
WolfGang Water Beading (Week 2) WolfGang Water Beading (Week 2)
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
WolfGang Water Beading (Week 2) WolfGang Water Beading (Week 2)
Overall Score:
5.28
Final Notes: We were hoping that the 2nd week results were an anomoly, but apparently they weren't. No improvement in beading or slickness, and optics are dropping off. Neighbors liked this product for ease of use, packaging and smell, but performance wise it didn't hold-up as well as we hoped it would. Again, it may benefit from the wash and QD/booster products, so your results may vary. Noticed some waterspots after panel was washed.




Zaino Brothers Z2 Show Car Polish

PRODUCT #7:
Zaino Z2 $12.95, 8oz


Initial Notes: Since Zaino has ruled just about every other test I've ever done, I decided to try something to handicap it a bit - I applied it without using ZFX or Z1 - I just wiped on some Z2, let it dry and wiped it off. Noticed that without ZFX, it took about 30 minutes to dry completely, and it removed just as easily as always. No streaking or hazing left behind. Surface was slick and smooth. Optics were bright and clear, but Z2 alone does little to help the appearance of the paint. It looked only slightly better than bare control panel. Pleasant scent, and efficient - 8oz bottle should provide 20+ applications for average vehicle.

Application: 10
Removal: 10
Packaging: 9
Instructions: 9
2-week Notes: Testers noted some loss in slickness, but water beading and optics remained strong and consistent. After final spray test, water beaded and ran off the panel in less than 15 seconds. Testers immediately said, "This must be the Zaino?" And they were right. The stuff has quite a "fingerprint."



Shine
Gloss
Depth
Clarity
Reflectivity
Slickness
Beading
Overall
TOTAL
Initial
7
7
6
8
8
10
10
8
8.50
Week 2
7
7
7
8
8
8
9
8
7.75
Week 4
6
6
6
7
7
6
8
7
6.63
Week 7
6
6
6
6
6
4
8
7
6.13
Average
6.5
6.5
6.25
7.25
7.25
7
8.75
7.5
7.25
Week 2:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Zaino Z2 Water Beading (Week 2) Zaino Z2 Water Beading (Week 2)
Week 4:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Zaino Z2 Water Beading (Week 2) Zaino Z2 Water Beading (Week 2)
Week 7:
Water Beading Photos (Immediate and 1 minute):

(Click to open in new window)
Zaino Z2 Water Beading (Week 2) Zaino Z2 Water Beading (Week 2)
4-week Notes: I don't know what to write that hasn't already been written. Nothing seems to phase this stuff. Optics down slightly, but not enough to really notice. Slickness down a bit as well, beading still doing great - watched water collect and run off the panel like it was on fire. Will continue to test until either Zaino or Einszett run out of gas. No waterspots present after panel was washed.
Overall Score:
7.25
7-week Notes: Before you start screaming "conspiracy" or crying that "I knew Zaino would win a Roadfly test," look at the pictures and read the test procedures. All of the process is clearly laid out, and I'm not *that good* at PhotoShop that I could magically draw beads and shine on a panel. Like it or hate it, the stuff is incredibly durable. Will it hide scratches? Nope. But, if you've got 1/2 a brain, you'll take care of all of the defects before you use a true Last Step Product. And for those who wonder why Zaino is always included in the tests? It's the benchmark - I'm looking for something that will *beat* Zaino...so far, nothing's come close. The stuff looks like new, even after seven hard weeks, and long after the other products gave up the ghost. Simply amazing.

CONCLUSION - WRAPPING IT ALL UP

Well, after seven long weeks, it appears that we have a clear winner. I was hoping the Einszett Glanz would keep up the fight, but I have a feeling the constant sun pounding really took a heavy toll on it. Granted, we live in an extremely hot climate, but I have to believe places like Arizona, Las Vegas, Dallas, Houston, and so on are as hot (if not hotter) than where we did the testing. Six solid weeks of life from Einszett is entirely acceptable - most folks will wax every 6-8 weeks, so I'm pleased with the results.

The clear winner was once again, Zaino. I'm sorry folks, but there's nothing I can say about the stuff that hasn't been said hundreds of times before. Read the 7-week Notes for final thoughts on the product. Simply put, it is the benchmark for which all other products should try to achieve. And no, I don't sell it, I don't have any interest in it, and I've never met the owners. I send in my money like everyone else does (although this Z2 is rather old - I need to reorder soon). If you're looking for reliable, bullet-proof durability with a high gloss, look no further.

As for the other products? We're all disappointed.

Many thanks to my neighbors, Rob, Ken, Keith, John and Kevin for their help. Without them, I couldn't have conducted a blind test and they were extremely gracious with their time by helping evaluate the products on a weekly basis.



-Steve

GURU REPORTS: Unbiased, independent, practical testing and evaluation of car care products.

 
 



 Detailing and Car Care Forum | Message Posts:



This message is closed to new posts.

Questions, comments, or problems, please visit the Roadfly help desk.
Roadfly.com Logo © 1997 - 2009 Jump Internet Inc. All rights reserved.